Comic #3480: 2014-11-27
Description
Comic Description:
- Panel 1: A character with long black hair and glasses speaks, illustrating a scenario. The background shows a fork in the tracks of an out-of-control train.
- Text: "Suppose you're in an out of control train. The train's path forks and you can either continue ahead or turn right."
- Panel 2: The same character continues to explain the consequences of inaction.
- Text: "If you do nothing, you ram into HITLER."
- Panel 3: The character explains the alternative choice.
- Text: "If you turn, you ram into TEN HITLERS."
- Panel 4: The character elaborates on the ethical implications of the choices.
- Text: "You could argue that if you ram ten Hitlers, you’ve killed more evil people, and you are therefore more ethical."
- Panel 5: The character presents a counterargument.
- Text: "Or, you could argue that by ramming only one Hitler, you achieve maximum remaining Hitlers. This will prevent any single Hitler from rising to power."
- Panel 6: A student in the class raises their hand to contribute.
- Text: "And THAT is the difference between virtue ethics and consequentialist ethics."
- Panel 7: The character suggests a different course of action.
- Text: "Maybe we should just try to find out who's cloning all these Hitlers."
- Panel 8: A student responds with a humorous remark regarding the classroom's focus.
- Text: "Pragmatism is not welcome in this classroom!"
Comic Signature: "smbc-comics.com"